Top 10 Craziest Craigslist Horror Stories // Subscribe: // TIMESTAMPS BELOW
CELEBRATE 10 YEARS OF WATCHMOJO WITH OUR SPECIAL EDITION MAGAZINE, LINKS BELOW! Everyone’s heard some creepy Craigslist personals, but what about when a Craigslist meet-up goes wrong? You might be trying to buy a bike, and a guy has his flaccid penis hanging out. Or baseball player Lenny Dykstra could hire you to do work on his house and allegedly expose himself to you. Or, a guy could be offering to sell his son for an Apple Watch. These are Craigslist encounters you’ll wish were missed connections. WatchMojo counts down ten of the scariest Craigslist stories that will make you never want to use the site again.

If you want to see more internet weirdness, be sure to watch our videos on the Top 10 Worst Facebook FAILS of All Time: , Top 10 WORST YouTube Scandals Ever: and Top 10 Biggest Google Fails: .

00:32 #10: Lenny Dykstra
01:13 #9: Apple Watch
01:49 #8: The Lure
02:21 #7: Flaccid
02:56 #6: The Graphing Calculator
03:30 #5: The Trade
04:10 #4: Sex Fantasy
04:52 #3, #2 & #1 ???

Special thanks to our users cdratel and mac121mr0 for suggesting this idea! Check out the voting page at

Our Magazine!! Learn the inner workings of WatchMojo and meet the voices behind the videos, articles by our specialists from gaming, film, tv, anime and more. VIEW INSTANTLY:

WatchMojo’s Social Media Pages

Get WatchMojo merchandise at

WatchMojo’s ten thousand videos on Top 10 lists, Origins, Biographies, Tips, How To’s, Reviews, Commentary and more on Pop Culture, Celebrity, Movies, Music, TV, Film, Video Games, Politics, News, Comics, Superheroes. Your trusted authority on ranking Pop Culture.


  1. Hmm, take a look at this Craigslist Related swag!
    The Craigslist Killer
    Craigslist Joe
    Craigslist Top Selling Secrets

    • +Brian Hill Let’s not mention probably the most famous Craigslist horror story of all time on our list of Top 10 of Craigslist horror stories. That would make sense!

      Side note, I stayed in that hotel once. Nice place.

    • Watchmojo I’m sorry everyone is hating on you ☹️ For the record I still love you guys…Especially when your doing lists like this instead of Anime and video games

  2. me at #2: “What could be worse than the Craiglist killer?”
    when #1 is played: “Oh shiiiiiiiiiiiiiii”

  3. wait… I’m confused what happened to the baby after the person was caught was it ever found

Comments are closed.